When Will We Leave The Bronze Age Behind?

Image for post
Image for post

There’s a serious tension — perhaps even a conflict — at the heart of even the most theoretically advanced schools of thought about more enlightened, humane, and effective ways to run businesses. Despite our efforts toward emergent leadership and away from command-and-control organizations, the notion that it all depends on a visionary leader is, to me, problematic.

My friend, Tom Nixon, wrote about this a few years ago, describing having dinner with Frederic Laloux and confessing that his Reinventing Organizations was ‘the best business book I ever read that I couldn’t quite bring myself to recommend to others. There was something going on for me, where the stories in the book didn’t seem to match the conclusions.’

And what was the snag? One of the goals of Laloux-style reinvention is to get to self-management, a decentralized system without formal hierarchy or ‘bosses’. But in Laloux’s characterization, the founder or CEO plays a special, centralized role:

I’m with Tom regarding how Laloux, and many others, continue to carve out a special, almost royal role for the founder/CEO, and perhaps for other ‘senior’ folks, as well. And it certainly sounds almost mystical, like the divine right of kings, whose authority is based on charisma, and the sense that their morals and virtue (in the Machiavellian sense) ennoble them, and put them above others. Certainly, the adoration of figures like Jobs, Gates, and Bezos in the tech realm is something like that. And to a lesser extent, that shine has reflected on CEOs and founders of companies of every size. Their authority is not like that of competent managers, like a Tim Cook, whose authority is derived from the efficient functioning of the business (Weber’s bureaucrats). No, we see something shinier, a halo, around these towering figures.

Don’t get me wrong. I believe that genius should be recognized, and that the iPhone, Windows, and Amazon have changed the world. But I think we need to lower the pedestal, in general, and move past the bronze age to more democratic models of organization.

Someday, perhaps, we will resolve this tension, which Tom refers to as a paradox. But not today, not in 2018.

Originally published at https://stoweboyd.com.

Written by

Work ecologist. Founder, Work Futures. The ecology of work and the anthropology of the future.

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store